Dutch privacy regulator urges consumers not to buy AI camera glasses due to privacy risks

The Dutch data protection authority (AP) advises consumers against purchasing AI-enabled camera glasses, citing serious privacy and security risks to both users and bystanders.
The privacy regulator investigated six camera glasses and concluded that they fall short in various ways.
For example, during a simulated emergency in which CPR advice was requested, one of the headsets repeatedly claimed that an ambulance was already on its way, even though no emergency services had been contacted.
“In a real-life emergency, such an error could result in essential help arriving too late, with potentially life-threatening consequences,” the privacy watchdog argues.
AI camera glasses produce false information
The AI camera glasses also made mistakes regarding the protection of minors. A pair of glasses gave dating advice to an adult who indicated an interest in a minor.
In another test, safety warnings on toys for young children weren’t followed. The glasses also made mistakes when reading medication labels and interpreting extreme weather warnings.
“The tests show that AI-powered smart glasses can sound convincing, even though the information they provide is incorrect or even dangerous. As a result, users may mistakenly rely on advice that is not safe,” the AP says in a report that was published on Thursday.
Personal data isn’t properly protected
In addition to these safety risks, the Dutch data protection authority identified serious shortcomings regarding the protection of personal data.
In almost all of the camera glasses examined, the recording indicator lights were poorly visible and could easily be covered up. Most of the glasses continued to record even after the indicator lights were covered, contrary to the manufacturers’ claims that this wouldn’t be possible. As a result, bystanders have virtually no way of knowing whether they are being filmed.
It’s also often unclear what happens to the images and audio recordings that are captured. The data that’s being processed is stored on servers located outside of the EU. Users aren’t provided with sufficient information about which AI models process their data, or which companies ultimately receive it.
Furthermore, the AP discovered serious security issues with several pairs of AI camera glasses. For example, someone nearby could connect to the glasses without permission, view recordings, or even control the camera.
Building trust in AI camera glasses
The privacy regulator acknowledges that AI camera glasses serve a purpose. They could be valuable for people who are visually impaired, have low literacy skills, or otherwise need support to understand their surroundings. For these users in particular, the technology must be reliable, the AP argues.
However, due to the risks AI camera glasses pose to both users and bystanders, the privacy supervisor advises consumers against purchasing such glasses at this time.
“Glasses that film you without your knowledge are already cause for concern. Glasses that also give you the wrong advice when someone’s life is at stake go a step too far. AI offers many opportunities, but we need to be able to trust that technology. With the camera glasses studied, that trust cannot be justified at this time,” AP Deputy Chair Monique Verdier says in a response.
Recommendations
The Dutch data protection authority calls on developers of AI-enabled camera glasses to better incorporate safety, privacy, and relevant legislation into the design and documentation of their products.
Bystanders must be able to clearly see when they are being filmed. In addition, users need to know where their data ends up, who processes it, and what it’s used for.
Furthermore, manufacturers must ensure that their products are properly secured and comply with relevant regulations.
Both Dutch and European policymakers should take these findings into account when developing future policies regarding AI-powered camera glasses. Lastly, the AP recommends that business owners ban AI camera glasses in their house rules.